Help Save A School From Overcrowding
Wednesday 24 May 2006
On my way home from work, I saw a group of protesters – penned in I should add – who were exercising their 1st Amendment rights of assembly and free speech to protest an act of brilliance by NYC Chancellor Joel Klein. What struck me is the hands-on lesson in civics and the Constitution. I saw grade schoolers learning first-hand how to stand up for their rights. I have posted the text of the school’s homepage for review. Any school that is willing to do this gets my vote. Screw textbooks and the Regents exam. What I saw was a living, breathing history/civics class.
Of course, I still disagree with the b.s. way that protesters are put in pens nowadays. Safety my ass. It’s demeaning and anathema to the intent of the framers of the Constitution. This 21st century practice needs to stop. Free speech and free assembly should be free.
From www.savethenest.org
Evidently, Chancellor Joel Klein’s chose to house an experimental charter school into one of the city’s public school buildings which already had a school in it. Klein, who is the honoree of the event, has demonstrated no concrete plan for how the two schools can share already occupied space, but has instead insisted that NEST+m “figure it out.”
NEST+m (New Explorations into Science, Techniology and Math), now in its fifth year, is New York City’s first and only K-12 public school, with its students achieving perfect or near perfect scores on every standardized test at every grade level* and a 100 percent graduation rate in its high school, which subsequently has had students admitted to Columbia, UPenn, Wesleyan, Yale and other outstanding post-secondary schools.
The rally to defend the educational excellence enjoyed by NEST+m’s extraordinarily diverse student population, which speaks 29 different languages and represents nearly every ethnic group in New York City will be held on Wednesday, May 24th at 5:30 pm. The PTA of NEST+m has filed a lawsuit against the NYS Board of Regents and the Department of Education (DOE) in response to Chancellor Klein’s move to squeeze the educationally unsound Ross Global Academy Charter School into NEST+m’s already crowded public school building.
The DOE’s plan to invade NEST+m’s space, which it hatched in concert with the Hamptons-based Ross Institute and New York University, has been in the works for two years. NEST+m only learned of it on March 28th due to a leak to the NEST+m Parent-Teacher Association. Since then NEST+m representatives, with the support of State Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, have met with Chancellor Klein, and DOE officials and, using the actual 2006-07 NEST+m enrollment figures and architectural diagrams, demonstrated that NEST+m – and any incoming school – would be seriously compromised by cramming the two into the building.
Nest+m administrators have argued that, in order to accommodate the charter school’s needs as “calculated” by the DOE, NEST+m’s high school would have to eliminate its honors, Regents, language and Advanced Placement classes, as well as electives and SAT prep, while increasing its class size from 20 to 35. The college preparatory school’s students would not be left with a skeletal program of core classes – rather they would be left lacking the courses required for admission to the sort of post-secondary schools for which they came to NEST+m to ready themselves. Klein and Harries, meanwhile, have insisted that this move will not adversely affect NEST+m, yet how can a college preparatory high school exist if it can’t offer the very classes that will ensure its students consideration for college placement?
Not only will the Ross thereby adversely affect NEST+m, but it will do so while “double dipping” into public funds. Ross claims in its Charter application that it is able to cap its class size at 20 (rather than 24) as a result of the savings garnered at the rate of $1.00 per year in rent it intends to pay the DOE for use of NEST+m’s physical plant, facilities, custodians, electricity, etc. as well as the $600,000 worth of facility renovations which NEST+m parents paid for, while Ross still collects funds from the Charter School Payments Act intended to cover these services. The Charter application also indicates that Ross is actually able to pay for a market rate lease, but that this will require increasing class size to 24 – a hardship indeed, while their unwillingness to compromise eliminates critical classes for our high school and pushes NEST+m’s class size to 35.
Meanwhile, NEST+m parents and students continue to urge their community and its leaders to take action to convince the Ross Global Academy Charter School that it would be best for all concerned if Ross were able to incubate in a place where it can do just that – incubate, not overtake. After all, how can a “Global” school make its very first act a Colonial takeover? How does one fit that into the curriculum?



Thursday 25 May 2006 at 10:46 pm
FINALLY! Someone got it! We are truly fighting for our civil liberties. Today in court the DOE dared to tell the judge that Chancellor Klein was above the Judicial system!
Not only that, but in answer to the petition we made for documents evidencing their proper notification of the charter proposal, the DOE lawyer “Chuck” only replied. “Its immaterial, your honor, since Chancellor Klein represents all of the New York Districts he technically gave notice to the Districts by giving notice to himself.”
I couldn’t make this up. Order the trial minutes…ITS THERE!
ugh….what’s this world coming to?
Lou G
Thursday 1 June 2006 at 2:27 pm
Lou, you sound as if the current occupants built the school facility with their bare hands? The buidling indeed belongs to the people of this great city. It is not the property of any particular faction. Where was all this passion when the previous occupants, JHS 22, was declared a so-called failing school made up of black and latino kids and closed?
Thursday 1 June 2006 at 2:41 pm
A note from the moderator:
The above comment was from one who, from what I can tell, wishes to remain anonymous. I will not voluntarily identify anyone who wishes for such anonymity without their consent. Anonymity is as vital as free speech to any democracy.
I take no position on the above comment and am not connected with it. I have made this an open forum and will keep it open without censorship except for outrageous conduct, meaning conduct that would shock the conscience.
I invite all points of view in the interest of fostering discussion.
embee (your moderator)
Friday 2 June 2006 at 12:22 am
Joel Klein is a man driven by vindictiveness and revenge toward Celenia Chevere, the Principal of NEST. Celenia personifies a Head of School who says “NO” to mediocrity; “Not here” to fuzzy math and ‘Consciousness of the Brain and Mind’ for science, but says “yes” to continuity, consistency, communication, and commitment. Klein could not care less about children…as he said about the NEST/Ross partnership, “all children will suffer equally”.
Friday 2 June 2006 at 12:32 am
The Charter school approval process has changed recently to a process whereby a single reader of a charter school application can approve a new school. This is what happened in the Ross Global Academy case. After the approval of the Ross Global charter school application, Joel Klein found the space…
Wednesday 7 June 2006 at 3:06 pm
The PTA of NEST+m in their spurious lawsuit against the Ross Global Academy have stooped so low as to make the ridiculous charge that “the Charter School will discriminate against Jewish students and employees” because “the Charter School will offer a mandatory Saturday program that will be part of the regular schedule… The Charter School has discriminated against Jews who comprise a large part of the population of New York City and the Lower East Side, in that any Jewish school-age child who observes the Sabbath, will not be able to attend the Charter School.” In their shameless zeal to keep several hundred of some of the neediest children of our city from receiving the excellent education that every child deserves, the parents of NEST+m and their “gifted,” entitled children have sacrificed the ideals of democratic public education on an altar of mendacity and cynicism. If “middle class” parents in a school of 730 students can afford to donate and raise $600,000 since 2001, and have the CHOICE to be driven from the public school system, then good riddance! The students of NEST+m are recieving an excellent education in the civics of exclusion.
Friday 9 June 2006 at 8:26 am
NEST+m parents are not responsible for the failure of JHS 22 or failed schools citywide. Why let the DOE and, in the past, the BOE, off the hook? NEST+m challenged the culture of failed schools in District One. Our school has the most important of all diversities…economic diversity. The “haves” can support the “have-nots”. Our PTA guarantees that no student is ever shut-out because of family income, even if that’s a $2,220 Senior trip to Europe. Show me another NYC public school where that happens!
We are proud of our diversity and our vibrant school community. The 50% of our school that are “middle class” have as much a right to attend public school as our lower income students do.
The public school system should not be the domaine of just the poor.
Friday 9 June 2006 at 12:28 pm
Parent Lou Gasco writes, “I LOVE NEST! Celenia Cheverez is a MODEL for driven executives and deserves her praise. Sure, she’s tough, but I have never met a CEO (and that is WHAT she is) of a multi-million dollar organization who wasn’t.
-From InsideSchools.Org
We reap what we sow, Lou. The business model of education worked for you until your comments (scroll up) suggested otherwise. Our mayor governs with a CEO’s mentality and our Chancellor is a lawyer, not an educator who does indeed have control of all the districts in the city: Ever since the BOE was centralized to form the DOE- very early on in Bloomberg’s administartion- parents have about as many rights as students in the public schools. That is, unless you want to lodge a formal compalint with your parent coordinator. It’s a top-down, anti-democratic system. By the way, principlas ARE NOT CEOs: No stockholdres, no profits to speak of… The business metaphor in education is overused and cynical. Children are human beings, neither economic quantities nor valuations of labor.
NEST sounds just to the right of Sparta and many of NEST’s parents and former parents seem to agree with that assessment. Go to insideschools.org Search for NEST+m.
Sunday 11 June 2006 at 9:19 am
http://www.savethenest.org
has received nearly 170,000 hits in 2.5 months!
What a surprise for the parents of NEST+m wow are trying to save their kids school.
Friday 16 June 2006 at 1:46 am
We should end debate this where our host, Hipster, started it. I’m not a NEST parent but I did visit their protest on Wall Street. I saw a dozen NYPD officers corralling score of “demonstrators”, mostly kids, into those pens normally associated with anti-globalization anarchists. The simple reality is that the parents and students made that school what it is. The donations were the least of it. The Chancellor can, and probably will, crush the NEST and take away their building. But all his socialite cronies and their money cannot will not recreate what the NEST community built.
Friday 16 June 2006 at 6:52 am
Patrick, while I cannot speak too informatively about the underlying debate, I have to say that the corralling of demonstrators, regardless of their cause, is a frightening trend from the last decade. The corralling, coupled with police, lends an air of criminality and makes what is patently Constitutionally-protected activity seem criminal. There are far too many attacks on our liberties from the current adminstration for me to list fully because my storage space is somewhat limited (that is being facetious).